Questions
AI ethics
Who is accountable when AI makes a mistake?
Accountability for AI-assisted hiring decisions can extend to both the company using the system and its supplier, depending on the case.

Why it matters
The issue has already reached courts and legislation: a court accepted that an AI supplier can be liable as an employer’s agent, and the EU AI Act requires human oversight and records for recruitment systems. But assigning a person to review a recommendation does not guarantee that they will challenge it.
What the evidence shows
- In Mobley v. Workday, the judge accepted the theory that the supplier can be liable as an agent of employers, without that being a final ruling on the discrimination allegations.Mobley v. Workday, Inc. · N.D. Cal., no. 3:23-cv-00770, N.D. California, 2023
- The EU AI Act classifies systems for recruiting, selecting and evaluating workers as high-risk, with duties including human oversight and records of what they do.Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, the AI Act · European Union, 2024
- In a hiring study, researchers found that even participants who rated the AI poorly followed its biased recommendations.No Thoughts Just AI: Biased LLM Hiring Recommendations Alter Human Decision Making and Limit Human Autonomy · Kyra Wilson et al., AIES 2025, 2025
What I would do
“The human is always responsible because, ethically, the human is the only one who is conscious, as far as we know.”
Why I think so:
- “Technology is not neutral: it carries the choices of those who build it and those who use it.”
- “AI without evaluation is a bet: measure before you promise.” where it comes from
- “A serious AI says only what it knows, shows where it got it, says when it does not know, and calls a person.” where it comes from
People also ask
- Who is responsible when AI gets it wrong?
- Can a company blame the AI?
- What is AI accountability?
