Questions
AI ethics
What is algorithmic monoculture?
Algorithmic monoculture is the use of the same or very similar algorithms by many companies, creating a risk that they all repeat the same mistakes. A model that is more accurate in individual assessments can still worsen overall results when many companies depend on it.

Why it matters
The problem goes beyond choosing a single provider: researchers found matching wrong answers even among models from different companies. In hiring, decisions linked to a shared provider can also close several doors to the same person instead of offering independent assessments.
What the evidence shows
- A theoretical study by Jon Kleinberg and Manish Raghavan shows that many firms using the same algorithm can reduce overall decision quality, even when it is more accurate than each separate evaluation.Algorithmic monoculture and social welfare · Jon Kleinberg, Manish Raghavan, PNAS 118(22), 2021
- A study found that when two models get the same question wrong, they choose the same wrong answer 60% of the time on average, with greater overlap among the most accurate models, even across companies.Correlated Errors in Large Language Models · Elliot Kim et al., ICML 2025, 2025
- A study of job applications involving a shared algorithm vendor found that 4% of people who applied to 10 jobs were recommended for rejection from all of them, more than chance would explain.Algorithmic Monocultures in Hiring · Rishi Bommasani et al., FAccT 2026, 2026
What I would do
I recommend measuring shared errors and keeping human checks before expanding AI use, rather than treating agreement between models as proof of correctness.
Why I think so:
- “The biggest risk is everyone being wrong the same way.” where it comes from
- “AI without evaluation is a bet: measure before you promise.” where it comes from
- “You can trust AI, if you check it.”
People also ask
- Why is it risky for everyone to use the same AI?
- What happens when every company uses the same model?
