Questions

AI ethics

Is AI biased in hiring?

AI can discriminate against candidates and favor a resume because of its position or wording rather than the candidate’s qualifications. Having a person check the recommendation does not guarantee fair hiring.

Newspaper clipping: an ad for a nanny that ends with “Positively no Irish need apply.”
A job ad from 1868: “Positively no Irish need apply.” Public domain. Wikimedia Commons

Why it matters

The EU AI Act classifies systems used to recruit, select and evaluate workers as high-risk, with duties such as human oversight and keeping records of what the system does.

What the evidence shows

  1. A study comparing equally qualified resumes across 70 professions found that 21 of 22 models preferred the resume shown first.Gender and positional biases in LLM-based hiring decisions: evidence from comparative CV/résumé evaluations · David Rozado, PeerJ Computer Science 12:e3628, 2026
  2. In a study of 528 people choosing candidates with AI assistance, even participants who rated the tool poorly followed its biased recommendations.No Thoughts Just AI: Biased LLM Hiring Recommendations Alter Human Decision Making and Limit Human Autonomy · Kyra Wilson et al., AIES 2025, 2025
  3. In a study using GPT-4, a resume given additional disability-related credentials ranked first in only 15 of 60 comparisons with its version without those additions.Identifying and Improving Disability Bias in GPT-Based Resume Screening · Kate Glazko et al., FAccT 2024, 2024
  4. In a preprint study, candidates who used the evaluator’s own AI model to write their resume summary had a 23% to 60% better chance of making the shortlist in a simulated selection.AI Self-preferencing in Algorithmic Hiring: Empirical Evidence and Insights · Jiannan Xu, Gujie Li, Jane Yi Jiang, arXiv; resumo estendido na AIES 2025, 2025

What I would do

I recommend measuring bias before expanding AI use in hiring, without treating human review as a guarantee of fairness.

Why I think so:

People also ask

  • Does AI discriminate against job candidates?
  • Is AI resume screening fair?
  • How does AI get hiring wrong?

Read next