Essays

An essay by Vitor Araujo

Tame, solve or cope.

New technology creates problems that rarely have clean solutions. Choosing how to face them is part of founding a company.

Essay

Engraving: Hercules raises his club against a many-headed hydra while Iolaus, on the other side, burns the severed necks with a torch.
Hercules and Iolaus kill the Lernaean Hydra, an engraving by Hans Sebald Beham (1545). Each head cut off grew back as two; Hercules won only when Iolaus began burning the stumps. CC0. Wikimedia Commons

What a wicked problem is

In 1973, Horst Rittel and Melvin Webber called problems wicked when they have no definitive formulation and no stopping point. Every attempt at a solution changes the problem, and answers are not right or wrong, only better or worse.

Most problems that new technology creates are socially wicked, deeptech above all: technology born from scientific research. Whether an AI should pick job candidates, and who answers when it gets it wrong, has no technical answer that settles it.

Three ways to deal with them

Political scientist Falk Daviter set out three strategies for these problems: solving, taming and coping. This is how I see them:

Solve is for problems we know can be solved. It takes broad coordination and slow agreements, and it is exposed to interventions by the most powerful players.

Tame is framing the problem and leaving some parts out, to reach precise, concrete results fast. The risk is being incomplete: what was left out comes back.

Cope is for when we know we can’t solve it. We iterate on damage control and incremental fixes to live with the effects. The risk is complacency, and losing sight of how to actually solve it.

What I do with this

Daviter concludes that none of the three always fits best. I agree. But whoever runs a startup is not only picking a strategy: they shape how the public will see and frame the problem. Sometimes they mold it at once; sometimes they anneal it, like a smith who heats metal and cools it slowly to take the tension out.

From the company-building side, I think taming is the right way most of the time. A company has to deliver something precise and concrete to exist. Once it becomes an established reality, we as a society have to come back to the problem and choose again: tame, solve or cope.

Tame to tame, tame to solve, or tame to cope. But first, tame to exist.

Sources

  1. Dilemmas in a General Theory of PlanningPolicy Sciences · Horst W. J. Rittel, Melvin M. Webber, 1973
  2. Coping, taming or solving: alternative approaches to the governance of wicked problemsPolicy Studies · Falk Daviter, 2017

Who writes this

I’m Vitor Araujo, an engineer and the cofounder of two startups. I write about technology, companies and ethics. More about me.